How Does Leadership Style Influence Decision Making: The Key to Making Better Choices.

how does leadership influence decision making

Leadership is an intricate dance, an artful act of influencing others to unite under a common goal. Within the space of leadership lies the crucial skill of decision-making. 

Every choice made by a leader carries the potential to steer their organization toward greatness or falter under the weight of missed opportunities. 

Exploring the interplay between leadership and decision-making provides leaders with valuable insights to adopt a versatile and adaptive approach, leverage their strengths, involve their team members, and foster a culture of trust and collaboration, ultimately guiding their organizations to success with greater insight and empathy.

In this post, we delve into the captivating interplay between leadership and decision-making, exploring how leadership theories, styles, and personal characteristics influence the choices leaders make. 

How Leadership Influences Decision Making

Leadership theories and styles, as well as personal characteristics, play a significant role in shaping the decision-making process. By examining these factors, we can gain deeper insights into the relationship between the leadership style and the decision-making process. 

1. Leadership Theories: Illuminating the Path to Sound Decision Making

Leadership theories serve as guiding beacons, offering frameworks that leaders can employ to navigate the treacherous terrain of decision-making. 

For instance, transformational leaders, with their ability to inspire and motivate, often involve others in the decision-making process, harnessing collective intelligence and fostering a sense of ownership. Conversely, transactional leaders tend to make decisions independently, relying on reward systems and exchanges.

2. Leadership Styles: Unleashing the Spectrum of Decision-Making Approaches

Leadership styles, akin to a kaleidoscope, bestow leaders with unique lenses through which they perceive and address decision-making challenges

Autocratic leaders, marked by their authoritative nature, tend to make decisions in isolation, holding firm to their vision. On the other hand, democratic leaders embrace participatory decision-making, valuing the insights and perspectives of their team members. By empowering others and building consensus, democratic leaders forge decisions with a stronger foundation.

3. Personal Characteristics: The Subtle Nudges That Shape Decision Making

Leadership and decision-making are deeply intertwined with personal characteristics, playing a pivotal role in the choices leaders make

The confident and decisive leader acts swiftly, trusting their instincts and driving progress. 

Meanwhile, the cautious and indecisive leader tends to deliberate more, meticulously weighing options before concluding. The blend of personality traits within a leader greatly influences the decision-making process, subtly sculpting the choices that shape their organization’s future.

Leadership Theories and Styles: The Spectrum of Possibilities

Within the vast domain of leadership, an array of theories and styles has emerged, offering leaders a palette of possibilities to color their decision-making approach. Let us uncover a few key theories and styles that have shaped the leadership landscape.

Trait Theory: The Essence of Leadership Embodied

At the heart of trait theory lies the belief that effective leaders possess certain inherent qualities that set them apart. These traits may include charisma, confidence, emotional intelligence, and resilience. 

While this theory sparks debates around whether leaders are born or made, it undeniably influences how leaders approach decision-making, leveraging their unique blend of traits to guide them.

Numerous studies have explored the connection between leadership traits and decision-making effectiveness. Research conducted by Judge, Bono, Ilies, and Gerhardt (2002) found that 90% of leaders exhibit high levels of Extraversion, Conscientiousness,  low Neuroticism, and Openness to Experience.  

Trait theory also emphasizes the significance of resilience in decision-making. A study conducted by Carmeli and Halevi (2009) explored the relationship between leadership resilience and decision-making quality. They found that leaders who possess resilience are better equipped to navigate complex and ambiguous situations, demonstrating the ability to adapt and make sound decisions under pressure. This highlights how leaders’ inherent traits, such as confidence, emotional intelligence, and resilience, play a substantial role in shaping their decision-making capabilities.

Behavioral Theory: Actions Speak Louder Than Words

Behavioral theory focuses on the actions and behaviors exhibited by leaders, examining how they influence the team. Leaders who display assertiveness, empathy, and adaptability tend to cultivate stronger relationships and inspire trust. When it comes to decision-making, leaders who exhibit rationality, openness to ideas, and effective communication are better positioned to inspire confidence in their choices.

Studies have demonstrated the impact of behavioral traits on decision-making. A study conducted by Metwally et al. (2019) explored the relationship between ethical leadership behaviors and a reduction in employee uncertainty. They found that leaders who demonstrate ethical behaviors, such as fairness, integrity, and transparency, are more likely to make ethical decisions that align with organizational values. This highlights the importance of leaders’ behavioral traits in fostering an ethical decision-making culture within their organizations.

Contingency Theory: The Dance of Leadership and Situational Demands

Contingency theory highlights the interplay between leadership effectiveness and the specific circumstances at hand. This theory suggests that the most effective leadership style is contingent upon the demands of the situation. Leaders who adapt their decision-making approach to suit the unique needs of each situation are more likely to achieve optimal outcomes.

A study conducted by Vroom and Jago (2007) explored the relationship between leadership styles and decision-making effectiveness in different situations. They found that leaders who exhibit a high level of task-oriented behavior are more effective in situations requiring quick and precise decision-making, while leaders who demonstrate a high level of relationship-oriented behavior are more effective in situations that demand collaboration and consensus building. This highlights the importance of aligning leadership styles with situational demands to enhance decision-making outcomes.

By embracing the insights provided by contingency theory, leaders can cultivate a flexible decision-making approach, tailor their leadership style to suit the demands of different situations and achieve optimal outcomes for their organizations.

The Transactional Theory or Management Theory: Navigating the Realm of Rewards and Exchanges

The transactional theory revolves around exchanges between leaders and their teams. Leaders employing this style focus on rewards and punishments, ensuring compliance and achieving set goals. 

Transactional leaders tend to make decisions based on established rules, procedures, and organizational norms. They prioritize efficiency and adherence to established protocols, which can be valuable in situations where quick and decisive decisions are necessary.

Transactional leadership also fosters a sense of structure and order within organizations, creating an environment where decisions are made efficiently and implemented effectively. This can be particularly beneficial in industries that require strict adherence to regulations or where standardized processes are critical for success.

However, it is important to note that transactional leadership alone may not harness the full potential of decision-making capabilities. While it provides a framework for efficient decision-making, it may not encourage innovation, creativity, or active engagement from team members. To leverage the benefits of transactional leadership while nurturing a culture of collaboration and innovation, leaders can integrate elements of other leadership styles, such as transformational leadership.

Theory of Transformation: Empowering Others to Reach New Heights

Transformational leadership transcends mere transactional exchanges, focusing on inspiring and motivating the team to exceed expectations. These leaders foster a sense of purpose and enthusiasm, empowering others to become active contributors in the decision-making process. By fostering collaboration and nurturing a culture of innovation, transformational leaders unlock the potential for groundbreaking choices.

A meta-analysis conducted by Judge and Piccolo (2004) revealed a positive relationship between transformational leadership and decision-making effectiveness. Transformational leaders tend to involve their team members in decision-making, seeking diverse perspectives and stimulating creativity. This inclusive approach enhances the quality of decisions by tapping into the collective intelligence and expertise of the team.

Transformational leaders also inspire a shared vision and provide a sense of meaning and purpose. A study conducted by Howell and Avolio (1993) found that leaders who exhibit transformational behaviors are more likely to foster a climate of innovation and risk-taking within their organizations. By encouraging new ideas and challenging the status quo, transformational leaders create an environment where innovative decisions can flourish.

It is important to note that the effectiveness of transformational leadership in decision-making is contingent upon the receptiveness and readiness of team members to embrace change and actively contribute. Transformational leaders need to establish trust, provide support, and empower their team members to fully leverage the benefits of this leadership style.

Situational Theory: Adapting the Leadership Approach to the Terrain

Similar to the contingency theory, the situational theory emphasizes the importance of adapting leadership styles to suit different situations. Leaders who showcase the flexibility to assess the needs of the moment and adjust their decision-making approach accordingly are more likely to lead their organizations through turbulent waters with poise and clarity.

In decision-making, leaders must consider the complexity of the situation, the expertise of the team members involved, and the urgency of the matter at hand.

For example, in high-stakes situations requiring quick decisions, leaders may need to adopt a more directive approach, providing clear instructions and guidance. Conversely, in situations that call for collaboration and creative problem-solving, leaders may need to adopt a more participative approach, involving team members in the decision-making process to leverage their expertise and diverse perspectives.

The ability to adapt leadership styles to suit different situations is crucial for navigating complexity, uncertainty, and change. Leaders who possess this agility can tailor their decision-making approach to optimize outcomes and adapt to the evolving needs of their organization.

Key Takeaways: Navigating the Crossroads of Leadership and Decision Making

As we reflect upon the intricate relationship between leadership and decision-making, several key insights emerge, illuminating the path toward making better choices.

  • Leadership and decision-making are inseparable, with each influencing and shaping the other. By recognizing this interdependence, leaders can better understand the impact their decisions have on their organization and its members.
  • Theories and styles of leadership can guide leaders in navigating the decision-making landscape. By embracing diverse perspectives and leveraging the strengths of different theories and styles, leaders can cultivate a more well-rounded approach to decision-making.
  • Personal characteristics hold profound sway over decision-making. By understanding their own traits and tendencies, leaders can leverage their strengths and mitigate their challenges, ensuring their decisions align with their organizational goals.

In this context, Personalysis emerges as an invaluable tool. Personalysis provides leaders with a science-based personality assessment that offers a clear roadmap to appreciate, respect, and work with the dynamic differences that exist between people. By unlocking a deeper understanding of oneself and others, leaders can engage in richer conversations, forge stronger working relationships, and foster seamless collaboration.

How Personalysis Can Help: Unleashing the Potential for Better Decision Making

Personalysis offers the most comprehensive personality assessment tool combined with leadership coaching and organizational consulting to assist leaders in elevating their decision-making style. Through these offerings, leaders can identify their unique strengths as decision-makers and gain insides into what others need to feel ready and confident to make a decision and take action.

Explore the wealth of leadership development solutions offered by Personalysis and unlock your full potential as a decision-maker.

Learn More Today! 


Contact us to see how we can help you, your team, or your organization reach full potential.

More Inspiration

The Power of Collaboration: Why Practical Team Communication Is Important In A Team And Leads To Success

In the vast expanse of teamwork, a singular force

Team Collaboration

In a world fueled by innovation and complexity, no

Team Collaboration